Twenty-Five Years
It has been a quarter century since the beginning of the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001. This is what I wrote almost five weeks later, on October 14, 2001:
It has taken more than a month to put pen to paper (or should I say electrons to CRT screen?) regarding September 11. Here are my assorted and disjointed musings.
- Time will tell what the next generation will call what today is known as “the war against terrorism,” but I have a feeling that the events that started it all will remain simply “September 11th.” More descriptive words seem horribly inadequate.
- I started a new job the day before, on Monday, September 10. Tuesday was the second day of 10 weeks of intensive formal training for me and 19 others. Being in class that morning, we didn’t learn what was happening until our first break, by which time the attacks were well underway. A fellow trainee, just transferred from another department, got a phone call from his former co-workers and relayed the developments to us. It was hard to work for the rest of the day.
- The destruction in New York is still too great for my small mind to grasp. Even after seeing the video a hundred times, I can’t fathom that the towers just aren’t there anymore. I’ll never forget my blank imcomprehension [sic] when my co-worker first relayed the news: “The first tower just collapsed,” and then just minutes later, “the second tower is gone.”
- It was shocking enough to hear that two commercial jets had been flown into the World Trade Center towers. But when I heard that another plane had hit the Pentagon, I thought we were being invaded. For the first time in my life, I understood war the way Europeans of my parents’ and grandparents’ generations understood it.
- I also had a flashback to my vacation last February when, in an attack of acrophobia while on the observation deck of Toronto’s CN Tower, I imagined a plane flying into the tower and sending us to our deaths. At the time my son laughed at my foolishness, but it doesn’t seem funny now.
- Contacting friends who may have been in the twin towers continues to be difficult. My cousin, who worked for Blue Cross in 1 WTC, got out safely and was driven by a kind trucker to Long Island where he boarded the ferry home to Connecticut. It took another two weeks before I heard from one of my sorority sisters who worked for the Port Authority and also got out safely. Another sister lives in Battery Park but was on vacation in Europe in September. Others remain unheard from.
- The only person I know who worked at the Pentagon had transferred out not long before the attack. Unfortunately, he left his Pentagon job to return to flight status as a Marine combat aviator and is now in Pakistan. So I embark on another round of correspondence reminiscent of the Gulf War in which he also served.
- And finally, excuse me for being testy, but I am growing weary of well-meaning Muslim leaders here in the United States warning other Americans not to associate them with the September 11 attacks. Most of us already know that the terrorists represent Islam about as much as the Nazis represented Christianity. The current danger is not that non-Muslims may misjudge Islam by these acts; the threat is from those Muslims who are mounting a hostile takeover from within Islam. It is a threat that can only be neutralized by the vigilant resistance of other Muslims. I pray they have the courage to do what they must.
My prediction in the first bullet point was almost spot on. Rather than “September 11th,” we now refer to the attacks as the shorter “Nine-eleven.”
Concern about friends not heard from turned out to be unwarranted; nobody I knew personally was killed that day. However, one friend who lived and worked in lower Manhattan subsequently developed multiple severe health problems likely attributable the toxic substances that permeated the air and blanketed the cityscape around ground zero after the collapse of the World Trade Center buildings. She died last year at age 52, one of countless additional victims of the attacks who will never be officially acknowledged. Another “casualty” was my cousin’s marriage to a man (referred to above as “my cousin”) who worked in the South Tower and was unhurt physically but not mentally, eventually walking out on his wife and children.
Another of my cousins, an Army officer, was deployed to Afghanistan as part of Operation Enduring Freedom. He had a non-combat role in a relatively secure compound, but since the Army was working with locals, the danger of infiltration and attack was ever present. He was unharmed while there and left the Army after a few more years, becoming a civilian instructor at West Point. But his exposure to the infamous burn pits of Afghanistan might very well have caused his recent prostate cancer, which is, fortunately, in remission.
My Marine friend got through his Pakistan stint just fine. He remained in the Corps, served as commander of a fighter squadron, and after 22 years retired as a Lieutenant Colonel. He now works in the civilian sector.
The last bullet point reflects a certain naivete about Islam. I have since learned that the Koran calls for Moslems to wage “jihad,” and many support it if not doing it themselves or abetting it. Year after year in the United States, we experience terrorist incidents by Moslems both American and foreign-born. In Great Britain, misogynistic Moslem men have victimized women and girls by the thousands. Other countries have faced attacks as well. Islam continues to motivate terrorism around the world, most notably but certainly not exclusively against the nation of Israel and Jews elsewhere. Persecution of Christians in Moslem countries is an ongoing problem. For those and other reasons, I am more distrustful of the ideology of Islam than I was before September 11, though I remain willing to judge people individually based on their own words, actions, and beliefs.
In 2002, on the first anniversary of the attacks, I listened to Mozart’s Requiem (K.626) as a small way of participating in a worldwide “Rolling Requiem” in memory of those lost. It remains one of my favorite works of classical music. If you have an hour to listen, here it is in its entirety.
O Christmas Tree: The Translation
If you enjoyed yesterday’s post comparing the lyrics of the Christmas carols “O Holy Night” and “Cantique de Noël,” I have another carol to look at today.
The German song “O Tannenbaum” was also translated into English. Let’s look at the first verse, comparing the original German with one version of English lyrics (there are several variations).
| German lyrics | Direct English translation | English lyrics |
|---|---|---|
| O Tannenbaum, O Tannenbaum, | O Christmas tree, O Christmas tree, | O Christmas Tree, O Christmas tree, |
| Wie treu sind deine Blätter. | How faithful are your leaves. | How lovely are your branches.* |
| O Tannenbaum, O Tannenbaum, | O Christmas tree, O Christmas tree, | O Christmas Tree, O Christmas tree, |
| Wie treu sind deine Blätter. | How faithful are your leaves. | How lovely are your branches. |
| Du grünst nicht nur zur Sommerzeit, | You are not only green in the summer, | Not only green in summer’s heat, |
| Nein auch im Winter, wenn es schneit. | No, even in winter when it snows. | But also winter’s snow and sleet. |
| O Tannenbaum, O Tannenbaum, | O Christmas tree, O Christmas tree, | O Christmas tree, O Christmas tree, |
| wie treu sind deine Blätter. | How faithful are your leaves. | How lovely are your branches. |
* Another version I’ve heard has this line as, “How steadfast are your branches,” which is closer to the German. There are several English versions, so your mileage may vary.
This is a truer translation than is the English translation of “Cantique de Noël.” But then again, this is a much simpler song.
We hereby conclude our foray into Christmas carols from other languages that have made their way into English. Unless, of course, I find another one…
A Christmas Carol: The Translation
Christmas is coming, and at this time of year the only music I listen to is Christmas music. I especially like religious carols. One of my favorites is “O Holy Night,” which is an English version of an old French carol, “Cantique de Noël.”
About ten years ago, I had to sing this song at Christmas Eve Mass in the original French. My church was the French-Canadian parish back in the day, and there were still a few old church ladies around from when the parish was more ethnic. The only problem was that I didn’t speak French and had no idea how to pronounce the lyrics. (French is not, I learned, pronounced like Spanish.) So a French-speaking friend went through the song with me, and I wrote it down phonetically and sang from that. I didn’t know what I was singing and didn’t especially care.
For some reason, I got thinking about that experience today. So I decided to look up the original lyrics and their direct translation to English, then compare the translation to the lyrics we sing today. If you’ve ever wondered, keep reading.
Read more…Getting Older Sucks
If we’re lucky, all of us get old. Some of us age better than others. A lot of it is genetic, such as when and how fast our hair turns gray, how many wrinkles we develop, and whether we develop coronary artery disease. A lot of it is behavioral, such how we eat and whether or not we exercise. The latter can affect the former.
I’m lucky to come from parents whose families have been mostly free of diabetes and heart attacks. That’s why I’ve been able to get away with some pretty unhealthy lifestyle choices, at least until now.
Today’s mail brought the results of the blood work from my annual physical, and let’s just say they aren’t pretty. My blood sugar is up slightly, total cholesterol is up more significantly, and triglycerides are through the roof.
Not that I should be surprised. I haven’t done any real exercise in years, my never-great eating habits have gotten even worse, and as a result my weight has continued to creep up. It doesn’t help that I turned 60 this year.
My doctor wants to put me on medication. I don’t want to take medication. Have you seen some of the side-effects of that stuff? Sure, those drugs can be literal life savers for the genetically cursed, but for many users they just a way to avoid healthier living. And it just doesn’t make sense to me to put up with muscle pain, gout, constipation, liver damage, dizziness, and a host of other uncomfortable symptoms just so I can eat cheesecake instead of salad.
That’s why I’ll be calling my doctor this evening (she is also a friend and a calligraphy client, so we usually talk after hours) to decline the drugs. I already take enough prescription medications for things I can’t fix without them, and I’m grateful to have them, but that’s where I draw the line.
And so it happens that I’m hauling out the portable stepper machine and starting a diet, nine days before Christmas. In classic procrastinator fashion, I considered waiting until the new year, but then I looked at those lab numbers again. It might not be as easy at my age as it once was, but I’m determined.
Wish me luck.
Speaking of turning 60, the last of the baby boomers will do so over the next couple of weeks, as the first of them are exceeding the average life expectancy. Here in the United States, that’s 77.5 years.
My now-deceased next-door neighbor once said that life was like a football game: 20 years is a quarter. If you make it to 80, you’re in overtime. That was funnier before I hit the fourth quarter.
Entering the twilight of life might be more palatable if I had grandchildren or money. That way, I could distract myself by spoiling cute little kids or setting out on spectacular vacation destinations. Come to think of it, I do have little kids to spoil: my 2-year-old godson, his 5-year-old brother and 7-year-old sister, collectively referred to as “my munchkins.” And just this past fall, I spent a glorious week in paradise, also known as Maui. (How did I survive so long without experiencing the blast that is snorkeling?)
I suppose it’s still possible that my son will settle down and have a family. And it isn’t completely impossible that I might someday win the PowerBall. But with she also comes wisdom, and the older I get, the more I appreciate what I have instead of complaining about what I don’t have.
For all my struggles in life (some self-induced, others not), I have been blessed in more ways than I can count. For those who doubt they can say the same, compate your life to famous and wealthy people have everything money can buy but are slaves to addiction, don’t know how to have good marriages, and/or can’t find meaning in their existence. In a way, those who have less are lucky because they learn to rely on what’s really important: faith, family, friends, and the things money can’t buy.
I’ll leave you with that thought. I’m off to visit my munchkins.
Israeli Apartheid, Genocide, Cease-Fire, and Other Myths
It’s been more than three months since Hamas’s massive terrorist attack on Israel on October 7, 2023. Almost immediately after the news broke of the attack, anti-Semites the world over took to the streets to celebrate and, in many places, continue to do so. Oh, they aren’t anti-Semitic, they’ll tell you, they’re simply against the country of Israel. Yet the victims of the October 7 atrocities weren’t members of Israel’s government or military*. They were infants, teenagers, parents, old people, and the disabled. Victims were raped, tortured, burned alive, beheaded, and taken hostage. Even in other countries, individuals and groups were and continue to be harassed, accosted, threatened, and assaulted, not because they are Israeli (they aren’t) but because they are Jewish. So yeah, the perpetrators are anti-Semitic.
I’m glad we cleared that up.
The thing you have to understand about anti-Semites is that they’ll always find a reason to hate on Jews. Always. The Egyptians enslaved Jews because they had become so numerous in their land of self-imposed exile that the Pharaohs, who imagined an army rising up to threaten their power, used force to keep them powerless. After the an Arab man named Mohammed created Islam on the Arabian peninsula in the early 7th century, Islamic armies of conquerors invaded large swaths of the Roman Empire, including the general region of Palestine, killing Jews (and Christians and others) for the made-up crime of refusing to convert to the new religion. The Nazis imagined unspecified damage caused by the “racially impure” Jews. Today, Arabs/Moslems, leftists, and other terrorist apologists go out of their way to project their own malfeasance and bad intentions onto Jews as personified by the nation of Israel. Why they so hate the Jews is another topic, which I will explore in a future post.
For now, let’s look at today’s de rigueur manufactured excuses: apartheid and genocide, and the related demand for an Israeli ceasefire.
Read more…I’m Back, Bitches
Hi, everybody!
I know. I’ve been away for a while. A ridiculously long while.
I briefly tried posting over on Substack, but I just didn’t like it as much as here. In other words, I missed this, my humble WordPress blog.
I did post two articles over at Substack, and I have republished them here, just within the last hour. If you aren’t reading this on the main page, here are the links:
I have a few more posts in the pipeline, some things I’ve been ruminating about for some time. Stay tuned.
Plastic Recycling? Not Me
Originally published on Substack on April 15, 2023
I was a bit of a hippie back in the day. I knew I was a feminist when they were called women’s libbers. I went through a mercifully brief vegetarian phase. And I became a bit of an environmentalist. I had a “Think Globally, Act Locally” sticker on my car, packed my son’s sandwiches in biodegradable cellulose bags, and used environmentally-friendly cleaning products even though they cost a fortune and weren’t available in most supermarkets.
When recycling became available in my town in, I think, the ‘90s, I jumped in with both feet. I loved the idea of my trash being transformed into something useful rather than just going to the dump. And I quickly realized that most of the non-paper material in my recycle bin was plastic.
There was so much plastic and paper in my waste stream that there were some weeks I didn’t even put out a bag of trash because I’m cheap and couldn’t see throwing out a tall kitchen trash bag that was less than half full.
For years, I recycled plastic. Correction: I didn’t actually recycle it. I put it in the bin, believing it would be recycled by someone else, thus averting ecological calamities like this:

It turns out I was wrong. All those apocalyptic warnings about plastic refuse clogging up our oceans, rivers, and lakes if we didn’t recycle it were b.s. And I found out from what I considered to be an unlikely source: a Greenpeace report.
Most plastic simply cannot be recycled, a new Greenpeace USA report concludes. Circular Claims Fall Flat Again, released today, finds that U.S. households generated an estimated 51 million tons of plastic waste in 2021, only 2.4 million tons of which was recycled.
The report also finds that no type of plastic packaging in the U.S. meets the definition of recyclable used by the Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s New Plastic Economy (EMF NPE) Initiative. Plastic recycling was estimated to have declined to about 5–6% in 2021, down from a high of 9.5% in 2014 and 8.7% in 2018. At that time, the U.S. exported millions of tons of plastic waste to China and counted it as recycled even though much of it was burned or dumped.
My bins and barrels full of plastic wasn’t being recycled at all; it was being sent to a country that has virtually no reason not to just dump it into the ocean. There were islands of plastic floating around not because we weren’t putting it into our recycle bins but because we were.
[Enter mini rant here] And therein lies the problem with many environmental mandates so popular in North America and Europe. It’s all smoke-and-mirrors. People presume that recycling is good for the environment because if it weren’t, our cities and states wouldn’t be pushing it. But the politicians who push it know nothing about what happens next. Worse, many environmental activists don’t tell them because a few hundred cubic miles of plastic floating around the world’s vast oceans is a small price to pay for getting bigger mandates passed: mandates for electric vehicles and bans on fossil fuels and so many other ideas that might be great in theory but simply aren’t ready for prime time in practice. But I digress. [End rant]
So, having had my consciousness raised by Greenpeace, I no longer recycle plastic. The contents of my bin now consist of cardboard, junk mail, old magazines, newspaper, and the occasional steel can or glass jar. The plastic all goes in the trash, which where I live gets incinerated and the ash sent to the landfill. I was briefly concerned about the pollution caused by burning the plastic, but then I learned that trash incineration technology has advanced to the point where the emissions contain virtually no trace of the plastic that was burned. The incineration process might even be able to generate energy.
What I’d really like to see, though, is less plastic. Instead of plastic milk jugs, could we go back to wax cardboard cartons which are still a thing for some milk? I’d even go for the crazy milk bags they use in eastern Canada, which are still plastic but a lot less of it. Things like soft drinks used to come in glass bottles, but I wouldn’t advocate a return to those because they weigh more and take up more space, both of which would dramatically increase shipping cost. Besides, anyone of a certain age remembers at least one time when a glass bottle of Pepsi fell out of the grocery bag and smashed into bits on the driveway. What a mess. But I digress. Again.
The point is that we all need to educate ourselves about the consequences of our actions, even (especially) actions pushed on us by possibly well-meaning but often ignorant politicians and bureaucrats. Sometimes, the solution to a problem is worse than the original problem. Let’s not let our enthusiasm for “progress” take us backward.
In Defense of the Bomb
The following commentary is not intended to be an argument about the morality of using nuclear weapons. I’m a Catholic, and I am well aware that almost every pope since World War II (except John Paul I, who hardly had time to do anything) has said, in one way or another, that the use of nuclear weapons is immoral. This post is merely an explanation of why I believe they are the most effective weapons ever invented.
Originally published on Substack on May 9, 2023
Would you think I was crazy if I told you that the atomic bomb was the best weapon ever developed?
The great (or, at times, not so great) thing about the interwebs is that you can start with one search goal and, with one thing leading to another, end up with something entirely unrelated but interesting. So it was when I went down the online rabbit hole yesterday and saw a trailer for Oppenheimer, an upcoming feature film about about the United States’ development of the atomic bomb.
Which that got me thinking that the atomic bomb really is the best weapon ever developed.
By way of background, it’s important to remember that World War II was really two wars. The Axis powers of Germany and Italy in the Eurocentric theater and Japan in the Pacific theater were allied only in the sense that they shared common foes. (The same could be said, of course, for the Allied Powers: the alliance of the Anglosphere and China with the Soviet Union was purely to defeat Nazi Germany, as we learned the instant the European war ended and Stalin replaced Hitler as Eurasia’s totalitarian aggressor.)
When the super-secret Manhattan Project was launched, it was an effort to beat Germany, not Japan, to be the first to build an atomic weapon. We knew Hitler’s scientists were working on a nuclear fission bomb; we even managed to poach some of them to our side. That the Nazis were defeated before either side won that race turned out to be rotten luck for the Japanese, who would instead be the ones to experience history’s most destructive weapon—twice—just three months after the European war ended.
The year 1945 brought the very real prospect that an invasion of the Japanese home islands was the only conventional way to finally defeat Japan. America’s two brand-new “atom bombs” presented a way to end the war with much less carnage that an invasion would cause. As horrible as the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were, they took fewer lives than would have been lost in a ground war in a country whose population viewed their emperor as almost a deity and were willing to fight to the death for him. Every Japanese citizen would essentially become a soldier defending his nation against invaders. Conservative estimates were that a million people—military and civilian, Japanese and American—would die in protracted combat.
So when President Truman compared the potential loss of life from the two alternatives, he chose to authorize the use of an atomic bomb. We now know that the emperor, following the advice of his high-level military commanders, refused to surrender after the destruction of Hiroshima, triggering the use of our second bomb on the city of Nagasaki. If he had known we didn’t have a third bomb, he might not have surrendered then, either.
Competing opinions of the morality of dropping those bombs persist to this day. Nuclear weaponry can kill in ways incendiary bombs can’t: astronomically high heat, radiation sickness, dehydration. The destruction wrought by the two atomic bombs dropped on Japan stunned the Japanese people, their leaders, and the world–so much so that, though many countries now have nuclear weapons 30-35 times more powerful than those we used against Japan, they have never been used.
The purpose of a nuclear arsenal is largely deterrent. Nations want to prevent being nuked by other, possibly rogue, countries or those with megalomaniacal leaders who wouldn’t mind incineration their enemies.
It’s called mutually-assured destruction, and it works. It’s why, when Valdimir Putin was rumbling about invading Ukraine during the administration of Donald Trump, Trump reportedly told Putin that if he did that, “We’re hitting Moscow.” Trump was crazy enough to make that threat believable, so Putin waited to invade Ukraine until someone considerable weaker than Trump was president.
Sure, everyone is terrified of the prospect of nuclear war, and some think the very existence of a nuclear attack is an existential threat to humanity. But that’s exactly why they’re such effective deterrents: because every country knows that if they launch a nuclear attack, they’ll get it right back.
The nuclear weapons are the only weapons in the history of warfare that have been used only once*. And that’s precisely what makes them the best weapons ever developed.
*Yes, I’m aware we dropped two bombs. I think it’s reasonable to consider them two events in the same action.
Mansplaining, Defined
gerund : any comment from a man to any woman who is looking for something to be offended about
Just a Little Reminder to the Rest of the World
Today is the American holiday of Memorial Day. It’s the equivalent of the day observed on November 11 in the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and some mainland European nations to commemorate their military service members who died in war. The date reflects the armistice ending the first World War. So why does the United States honor their war dead every year almost six months earlier?
For one thing, Memorial Day predates World War I by several decades. It is believed to have been first observed on May 30, 1868, three years after the end of the American Civil War, at the direction of Gen. John Logan, Grand Army of the Republic (the organization of Union veterans of the Civil War). It was originally called Decoration Day because women would use the occasion to decorate the graves of dead Civil War soldiers, a common practice going back centuries. While other Civil War remembrances took place in both north and south before the first Decoration Day, May 30, 1868 marks the first organized observance of what would by 1890 become a holiday in every northern state.
By the time a 1967 act of Congress officially named the holiday “Memorial Day,” the observance had come to include the military dead of the two World Wars and the Korean War. In 1971, the official observance of the holiday was changed to the last Monday in May in order to create a long holiday weekend. (The law also moved observance of Washington’s birthday, Labor Day, and Columbus Day to Mondays; Martin Luther King, Jr.’s Birthday would join the Monday holidays in 1986.)
Not that the United States failed to commemorate the end of World War I. On the contrary, November 11 was celebrated as Armistice Day unofficially from 1919 and became a legal Federal holiday in 1938. Following the second World War, the end of which was also noteworthy, Congress renamed the holiday Veterans Day in 1954 and left the memorializing of war dead to the end of May.
All of which is a long way of saying that we celebrate Memorial Day instead of Remembrance Day because Memorial Day was established first. And that’s how it came to be that we Americans remember our military countrymen and countrywomen who died in war on the last Monday in May and honor all our mitary veterans on November 11.

















